So, I followed a link to a “how to tie a tie” video to make fun of it. I consider myself an excellent tie tier, and scoff at double windsors unless they have an attractive demple coming out of the knot.
But what is so interesting about the link was the polls that are displayed below the video. Here are the polls and the results:
Poll: Assuming prices remained the same, would you rather…
[1] Make $50,000 in a world where everyone makes $25,000; or
[2] Make $100,000 in a world where everyone makes $200,000.
62.14% chose option 1. Maybe people don’t get the “assuming prices remained the same” thing, but they are choosing to be worse off overall just to be better off in relation to their peers.
The second poll asks: Would you give up the last 5 years of life for $5,000,000 now?
62.15% said no.
Again, this is curious to me. I personally believe that the point of living is not just to be alive, but to gather experiences and spread goodness and love (OK, I’m part hippe, I admit). $5MM right now will definitely open up more opportunities for experiences than the last 5 years of life wearing diapers and watching TV. I’m not even going to go into the whole time value of money thing.
Of course, the survey is extremely unscientific, probably skewed (based on the theme of the website’s book), and possibly fraudulent (I am only suspicious because the breakdown of the two questions are the same. Hrmmm.).
However, assuming that this is representative of at least some segment of the general population, the insight is fascinating. In general, middle class America is much better off than we were 10 years ago, but our lifestyle gains have not kept pace with our upper-middle class peers. The rich are getting richer. The not-rich are getting richer, but not near as fast as the rich. That provides a lot of angst in a world where people’s values are as reflected in this casual poll.
Similarly, the polls are somewhat related. Many studies out there report that wages, when inflation is considered, have fallen flat. One criticism of many of these studies is that they do not take into account the significant increases in healthcare benefits provided by employers. This increase in compensation is largely taken for granted in our society. While I do not doubt that the rich are getting richer faster than the not-rich, the idea that middle class is stuck in the mud is often repeated, but not really that convincing to me.
I’m just not on board with the majority in these polls.